Fire Chief Slams Giuliani, Calls White House Inaction 'National
As the 2008 presidential race grows more like the early days of the
year 2000 New York Senate race between Hillary Clinton and Rudy
Giuliani, nothing is holding back critics of either candidate. However
on 9 March 2007 The International Association of Fire Fighters slammed
Giuliani --in particular-- for how he handled the World Trade Center
clean-up in the aftermath of terrorist attacks on 11 September 2001.
The union president further condemned President George W Bush for
absence of federal leadership in Louisiana where much of the areas hit
by flooding in August 2005 remained devastated to this day.
With union president Harold Schaitberger's first point, he wants
everyone to know "the real story" behind 9.11 clean-up in New York
City, and told his members that --as mayor of New York-- Giuliani
sought to curtail search-and-recovery efforts at the World Trade Center
site quickly in effort to get back to business as usual without an
"Mayor Giuliani's actions meant that fire fighters and citizens who
perished would either remain buried at Ground Zero forever, with no
closure for families, or be removed like garbage and deposited at the
Fresh Kills Landfill," wrote union president Schaitberger.
The World Trade Center debris clean-up was fairly quick considering no
such effort to date had been undertaken in the United States. Building
rubble and all other items --including millions in cash, and millions
of dollars worth of gold, and other precious metals-- from within the
fallen buildings were shipped to a high-security sorting facility and
disposed of "properly," according to authorities. Ultimately the
clean-up took half as long as original estimates suggested.
"He valued the money and gold and wanted the site cleared before he
left office at the end of 2001 more than he valued the lives and
memories of those lost," Schaitberger wrote.
Not all firefighters agree with Schaitberger however. Former fireman
Tim Brown, who works on the Giuliani campaign, said there was no lack
of support for the former mayor. "We are honored by the support of so
many first responders from across the country and are appreciative of
their continued enthusiasm for mayor Giuliani's candidacy," Brown said.
The International Association of Fire Fighters further warned the
United States that the nation was no better prepared for a 9.11 type of
terrorist attack today than was the case in September 2001.
Schaitberger delivered the sharp criticism to a House appropriations
subcommittee. The union's claim is in stark contrast with the White
House's efforts to curb terrorist threats at home and abroad.
Schaitberger urged members of the subcommittee on homeland security to
demand that grants are allocated on the basis of risk, as recommended
by the 9/11 Commission, and to fully fund programs designed to ensure
baseline capabilities for local fire departments, which are
understaffed and not getting the necessary training.
According to Department of Homeland Security funding schedules, grant
"encourage misuse" by requiring localities with little homeland
security need to “use or lose” appropriations.
“The result is such infamous purchases as the seven security cameras to
protect a remote Alaskan fishing village,” Schaitberger quipped.
Another program, the Urban Area Security Initiative has been tainted by
politics, with high-profile urban areas slighted in favor of smaller
communities that don’t need the terrorism security investment, he said.
The union president said the federal government should have spent
the past (almost) six years since the attack to enhance citizen
preparedness and to fully fund the Staffing for Adequate Fire and
Emergency Response (SAFER) grants, which is currently funded for 11
“When local communities are forced to assume an ever-increasing share
of the costs of maintaining a (search and rescue) team, the extra funds
inevitably come from existing public safety budget accounts, which
weakens local emergency preparedness,” he said.
Another example of failure by the White House has been in New Orleans,
LA, Schaitberger said. The city was not only ill-prepared for hurricane
Katrina and its aftermath, but the city remains largely uninhabitable
18 months later.
He urged Congress to amend the Stafford Act, requiring local matches to
receive federal funds, to allow such devastated areas as St. Bernard’s
Parish to rebuild emergency service infrastructure. All 10 of the St.
Bernard firehouses were destroyed. “Because more than two-thirds of St.
Bernard residents have not returned to their homes, the parish does not
have the tax base to provide the local match for funds, which are
sitting idle,” Schaitberger said.
“My members in the Gulf area are working out of fire stations with
leaking roofs, and in many cases with no roofs,” he said. “Mold is
widespread, and open sewage common. This is unacceptable and failure of
our government to address this issue, 18 months after the storms, is a
content is copyrighted by
Ask, reproduction of any kind is not permitted without written